Nota

This page was generated from tutorials/algorithms/02_vqe_advanced_options.ipynb.

Advanced VQE Options

In the first algorithms tutorial, you learned how to set up a basic VQE algorithm. Now, you will see how to provide more advanced configuration parameters to explore the full range of capabilities of Qiskit’s variational algorithms: VQE, QAOA and VQD among others. In particular, this tutorial will cover how to set up a callback to monitor convergence and the use of custom initial points and gradients.

Callback

Callback methods can be used to monitor optimization progress as the algorithm runs and converges to the minimum. The callback is invoked for each functional evaluation by the optimizer and provides the current optimizer value, evaluation count, current optimizer parameters etc. Note that, depending on the specific optimizer this may not be each iteration (step) of the optimizer, so for example if the optimizer is calling the cost function to compute a finite difference based gradient this will be visible via the callback.

This section demonstrates how to leverage callbacks in VQE to plot the convergence path to the ground state energy with a selected set of optimizers.

First, you need a qubit operator for VQE. For this example, you can use the same operator as used in the algorithms introduction, which was originally computed by Qiskit Nature for an H2 molecule.

from qiskit.quantum_info import SparsePauliOp

H2_op = SparsePauliOp.from_list(
    [
        ("II", -1.052373245772859),
        ("IZ", 0.39793742484318045),
        ("ZI", -0.39793742484318045),
        ("ZZ", -0.01128010425623538),
        ("XX", 0.18093119978423156),
    ]
)

The next step is to instantiate the Estimator of choice for the evaluation of expectation values within VQE. For simplicity, you can select the qiskit.primitives.Estimator shipped with the default Qiskit Terra installation.

from qiskit.primitives import Estimator

estimator = Estimator()

You are now ready to compare a set of optimizers through the VQE callback. The minimum energy of the H2 Hamiltonian can be found quite easily, so the maximum number of iterations (maxiter) does not have to be very large. You can once again use TwoLocal as the selected trial wavefunction (i.e. ansatz).

import numpy as np
from qiskit.algorithms.minimum_eigensolvers import VQE
from qiskit.algorithms.optimizers import COBYLA, L_BFGS_B, SLSQP
from qiskit.circuit.library import TwoLocal
from qiskit.utils import algorithm_globals

# we will iterate over these different optimizers
optimizers = [COBYLA(maxiter=80), L_BFGS_B(maxiter=60), SLSQP(maxiter=60)]
converge_counts = np.empty([len(optimizers)], dtype=object)
converge_vals = np.empty([len(optimizers)], dtype=object)

for i, optimizer in enumerate(optimizers):
    print("\rOptimizer: {}        ".format(type(optimizer).__name__), end="")
    algorithm_globals.random_seed = 50
    ansatz = TwoLocal(rotation_blocks="ry", entanglement_blocks="cz")

    counts = []
    values = []

    def store_intermediate_result(eval_count, parameters, mean, std):
        counts.append(eval_count)
        values.append(mean)

    vqe = VQE(estimator, ansatz, optimizer, callback=store_intermediate_result)
    result = vqe.compute_minimum_eigenvalue(operator=H2_op)
    converge_counts[i] = np.asarray(counts)
    converge_vals[i] = np.asarray(values)

print("\rOptimization complete      ");

Optimization complete

Now, from the callback data you stored, you can plot the energy value at each objective function call each optimizer makes. An optimizer using a finite difference method for computing gradient has that characteristic step-like plot where for a number of evaluations it is computing the value for close by points to establish a gradient (the close by points having very similar values whose difference cannot be seen on the scale of the graph here).

import pylab

pylab.rcParams["figure.figsize"] = (12, 8)
for i, optimizer in enumerate(optimizers):
    pylab.plot(converge_counts[i], converge_vals[i], label=type(optimizer).__name__)
pylab.xlabel("Eval count")
pylab.ylabel("Energy")
pylab.title("Energy convergence for various optimizers")
pylab.legend(loc="upper right");

Finally, since the above problem is still easily tractable classically, you can use NumPyMinimumEigensolver to compute a reference value for the solution.

from qiskit.algorithms.minimum_eigensolvers import NumPyMinimumEigensolver
from qiskit.opflow import PauliSumOp

numpy_solver = NumPyMinimumEigensolver()
result = numpy_solver.compute_minimum_eigenvalue(operator=PauliSumOp(H2_op))
ref_value = result.eigenvalue.real
print(f"Reference value: {ref_value:.5f}")

Reference value: -1.85728

You can now plot the difference between the VQE solution and this exact reference value as the algorithm converges towards the minimum energy.

pylab.rcParams["figure.figsize"] = (12, 8)
for i, optimizer in enumerate(optimizers):
    pylab.plot(
        converge_counts[i],
        abs(ref_value - converge_vals[i]),
        label=type(optimizer).__name__,
    )
pylab.xlabel("Eval count")
pylab.ylabel("Energy difference from solution reference value")
pylab.title("Energy convergence for various optimizers")
pylab.yscale("log")
pylab.legend(loc="upper right");

Gradients

In Qiskit’s variational algorithms, if the provided optimizer uses a gradient-based technique, the default gradient method will be finite differences. However, these classes include an option to pass custom gradients via the gradient parameter, which can be any of the provided methods within Qiskit’s gradient framework, which fully supports the use of primitives. This section shows how to use custom gradients in the VQE workflow.

The first step is to initialize both the corresponding primitive and primitive gradient:

from qiskit.algorithms.gradients import FiniteDiffEstimatorGradient

estimator = Estimator()
gradient = FiniteDiffEstimatorGradient(estimator, epsilon=0.01)

Now, you can inspect an SLSQP run using the FiniteDiffEstimatorGradient from above:

algorithm_globals.random_seed = 50
ansatz = TwoLocal(rotation_blocks="ry", entanglement_blocks="cz")

optimizer = SLSQP(maxiter=100)

counts = []
values = []


def store_intermediate_result(eval_count, parameters, mean, std):
    counts.append(eval_count)
    values.append(mean)


vqe = VQE(
    estimator, ansatz, optimizer, callback=store_intermediate_result, gradient=gradient
)

result = vqe.compute_minimum_eigenvalue(operator=H2_op)
print(f"Value using Gradient: {result.eigenvalue.real:.5f}")

Value using Gradient: -1.85728

pylab.rcParams["figure.figsize"] = (12, 8)
pylab.plot(counts, values, label=type(optimizer).__name__)
pylab.xlabel("Eval count")
pylab.ylabel("Energy")
pylab.title("Energy convergence using Gradient")
pylab.legend(loc="upper right");

Initial point

By default, the optimization begins at a random point within the bounds defined by the ansatz. The initial_point option allows to override this point with a custom list of values that match the number of ansatz parameters.

You might wonder… Why set a custom initial point? Well, this option can come in handy if you have a guess for a reasonable starting point for the problem, or perhaps know information from a prior experiment.

To demonstrate this feature, let’s look at the results from our previous VQE run:

print(result)
cost_function_evals = result.cost_function_evals

{   'aux_operators_evaluated': None,
    'cost_function_evals': 9,
    'eigenvalue': -1.8572750175655812,
    'optimal_circuit': <qiskit.circuit.library.n_local.two_local.TwoLocal object at 0x13ef7dd20>,
    'optimal_parameters': {   ParameterVectorElement(θ[0]): 4.296519450348719,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[3]): 6.092947832767056,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[1]): 4.426962358395531,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[7]): 0.36021017470898664,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[4]): -2.598326651673288,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[5]): 1.5683250498282322,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[2]): 0.5470777607659094,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[6]): -4.717616147449751},
    'optimal_point': array([ 4.29651945,  4.42696236,  0.54707776,  6.09294783, -2.59832665,
        1.56832505, -4.71761615,  0.36021017]),
    'optimal_value': -1.8572750175655812,
    'optimizer_evals': None,
    'optimizer_result': <qiskit.algorithms.optimizers.optimizer.OptimizerResult object at 0x13010b6a0>,
    'optimizer_time': 0.3502693176269531}

Now, you can take the optimal_point from the above result and use it as the initial_point for a follow-up computation.

Note: initial_point is now a keyword-only argument of the VQE class (i.e, it must be set following the keyword=value syntax).

initial_pt = result.optimal_point

estimator1 = Estimator()
gradient1 = FiniteDiffEstimatorGradient(estimator, epsilon=0.01)
ansatz1 = TwoLocal(rotation_blocks="ry", entanglement_blocks="cz")
optimizer1 = SLSQP(maxiter=1000)

vqe1 = VQE(
    estimator1, ansatz1, optimizer1, gradient=gradient1, initial_point=initial_pt
)
result1 = vqe1.compute_minimum_eigenvalue(operator=H2_op)
print(result1)

cost_function_evals1 = result1.cost_function_evals
print()

{   'aux_operators_evaluated': None,
    'cost_function_evals': 1,
    'eigenvalue': -1.8572750175655812,
    'optimal_circuit': <qiskit.circuit.library.n_local.two_local.TwoLocal object at 0x1411b9780>,
    'optimal_parameters': {   ParameterVectorElement(θ[0]): 4.296519450348719,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[1]): 4.426962358395531,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[4]): -2.598326651673288,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[5]): 1.5683250498282322,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[3]): 6.092947832767056,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[2]): 0.5470777607659094,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[6]): -4.717616147449751,
                              ParameterVectorElement(θ[7]): 0.36021017470898664},
    'optimal_point': array([ 4.29651945,  4.42696236,  0.54707776,  6.09294783, -2.59832665,
        1.56832505, -4.71761615,  0.36021017]),
    'optimal_value': -1.8572750175655812,
    'optimizer_evals': None,
    'optimizer_result': <qiskit.algorithms.optimizers.optimizer.OptimizerResult object at 0x1411e3f10>,
    'optimizer_time': 0.05097508430480957}

print(
    f"cost_function_evals is {cost_function_evals1} with initial point versus {cost_function_evals} without it."
)

cost_function_evals is 1 with initial point versus 9 without it.

By looking at the cost_function_evals you can notice how the initial point helped the algorithm converge faster (in just 1 iteration, as we already provided the optimal solution).

This can be particularly useful in cases where we have two closely related problems, and the solution to one problem can be used to guess the other’s. A good example might be plotting dissociation profiles in chemistry, where we change the inter-atomic distances of a molecule and compute its minimum eigenvalue for each distance. When the distance changes are small, we expect the solution to still be close to the prior one. Thus, a popular technique is to simply use the optimal point from one solution as the starting point for the next step. There also exist more complex techniques, where we can apply extrapolation to compute an initial position based on prior solution(s) rather than directly use the prior solution.

import qiskit.tools.jupyter

%qiskit_version_table
%qiskit_copyright

Version Information

Qiskit Software	Version
qiskit-terra	0.22.2
qiskit-aer	0.11.1
qiskit-ignis	0.7.1
qiskit-ibmq-provider	0.19.2
qiskit	0.39.2
System information
Python version	3.10.2
Python compiler	Clang 13.0.0 (clang-1300.0.29.30)
Python build	v3.10.2:a58ebcc701, Jan 13 2022 14:50:16
OS	Darwin
CPUs	8
Memory (Gb)	64.0
Fri Nov 18 01:08:34 2022 CET

This code is a part of Qiskit

© Copyright IBM 2017, 2022.

This code is licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0. You may
obtain a copy of this license in the LICENSE.txt file in the root directory
of this source tree or at http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0.

Any modifications or derivative works of this code must retain this
copyright notice, and modified files need to carry a notice indicating
that they have been altered from the originals.